Why an English manifesto must be part of Labour’s Democracy Review

The Labour Party has launched its Democracy Review, led by former MP and Corbyn aide Katy Clark. The review aims “to ensure that the hugely expanded membership is fully involved to become a mass movement which can transform society”.

The English Labour Network will ask the review to support the publication of an English manifesto at the next election. An English manifesto should be the vehicle to take Labour’s message to English voters, and an opportunity for English Labour members to shape policy for England. You can lend your support to the campaign here.

Writing for LabourList recently, our founding supporters Shabana Mahmood MP and John Denham explained that:

“In Wales and Scotland, the party is clear. We have a Welsh manifesto and a Scottish manifesto. In England, it has always been much murkier. There is no English manifesto. Instead, the UK Labour manifesto mixes up policy on issues that will only apply in England – health, schools, universities, apprenticeship, most transport, social care and many other areas – with issues that affect the whole of the UK.

“There’s a high price to pay for that muddle. We give the impression that Labour doesn’t really think England exists; or that England and the UK are just the same thing. Labour should go into the next election with a clear, English manifesto.”

Labour must win England, yet too often our support lags amongst voters who feel English but are not yet convinced Labour speaks for them.

The  2017 manifesto was a big step forward in recognising England. It proposed a Minister for England, it renewed our calls for a constitutional convention and, for the first time, proposed a “relationship of equals” between England, Wales and Scotland. But it left a lot to be fleshed out. It said we were the party of devolution, but nothing about the balance of power between the centre and local areas; between ministers and elected local leaders, between north, south and London.

Now we must take the next step and publish a manifesto that sets out clearly our policies for England and how England should be governed.

We are a unionist party, but England has its own history; sometimes conservative but often of radical struggles for rights and fairness that are still relevant today. We should have the pride to tell that story. We must also ensure that the Englishness we celebrate is progressive, inclusive and reflects the England we live in today. 

Don’t forget to lend your support to the campaign here. We will soon be approaching English Labour Network members to support us with our campaign, but if you are particularly keen to be involved, or have any ideas you’d like to share, please get in touch.

One comment

  1. As a 73 year old gay person I have always felt English, rather than British, though born in south London. To me Britain refers to the UK, the monarchy, the union jack flag, the old empire and the tories. England refers to the Chartist struggle, the English revolution – the Levellers and even further back to the revolt of the peasants at the time of Watt Tyler in the middle ages. English is also the colour of the various local customs and culture of the many indigenous communities to be found in England – yet all having a common thread of nationality which the british rubric completely lacks. I realise this can sound a bit silly but of course one can go a lot deeper and no doubt there are progressive researchers, scholars and historians who do when referring to our Englishness. But what the English people do desperately need is the sense that Yes we are a people with a history and it’s not all about bashing foreign peoples but our own struggles against one of the most rapacious ruling classes in world history. England needs to break the Westminster ties that bind it – we need a new English Parliament – a new round parliament perhaps located in the centre of our country – perhaps Nottingham ( already having infrastructure such as road, rail and the Robin Hood airport). A parliament with an upper and lower house both elected etc. And it’s not a racist gambit at all as English people hail from all over the planet and always have.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s